How California’s Insurance Crisis Affects Pool Owners in 2024

California neighborhood with swimming pool near a wildfire, illustrating homeowners' insurance challenges due to climate risks

Governor Gavin Newsom’s recent executive order addresses California’s growing homeowners’ insurance crisis by allowing insurers to factor in climate-related risks when setting rates. While this aims to stabilize the insurance market and retain providers, the pool industry faces unique challenges. These issues underscore the importance of understanding how insurance trends impact pool owners and the steps they can take to protect their investments.


What Is California’s Homeowners’ Insurance Crisis?

California’s homeowners’ insurance market has faced growing strain due to climate-related risks such as wildfires and drought. Many insurers have exited the state, citing unsustainable losses. In response, Governor Newsom’s executive order directs the insurance commissioner to consider climate-related risks in rate-setting, offering insurers more flexibility to remain in the market.


Why Does This Matter to Pool Owners?

Policy Cancellations and Premium Hikes

Many pool owners have seen their policies canceled or premiums dramatically increase. Pools can be perceived as liabilities, especially when associated with water usage and potential damage to properties. Notably, a California couple lost their homeowners’ insurance after draining their swimming pool to conserve water, illustrating how even well-intentioned actions can lead to unexpected consequences.

Drought and Fire Risks

As drought conditions persist, pools are often viewed as symbols of excessive water use, despite their role in fire prevention. A filled pool can serve as an emergency water source during wildfires, yet insurance companies frequently overlook this benefit, complicating coverage for pool owners.
Backyard swimming pool with fire-resistant landscaping


Who Is Most Affected?

Homeowners in High-Risk Areas

Pool owners in wildfire-prone regions face higher risks of policy cancellations or non-renewals. Insurers are reluctant to cover properties in these areas, leading to limited options and higher costs.

Pool Owners Seeking New Policies

For homeowners looking to install or maintain a pool, securing affordable insurance has become increasingly challenging. Insurers now scrutinize climate risks more closely, making it harder to find comprehensive coverage.


How Can Pool Owners Protect Themselves?

Documenting the Pool’s Benefits

Pool owners should highlight how their pools can mitigate fire risks and contribute to property safety. Detailed documentation, including maintenance records and water conservation strategies, can help reassure insurers.

Exploring Specialized Insurance Options

Homeowners can seek policies tailored for properties with pools. Specialized insurers may offer more flexible terms that recognize pools’ dual role as an amenity and a fire safety feature.

Working with Advocacy Groups

Organizations like the California Pool Association can provide resources and advocacy for pool owners. The association collaborates with insurers and regulators to promote fair policies and educate homeowners about best practices.


What Are the Implications for the Pool Industry?

Increased Demand for Risk Assessment Services

The insurance crisis has heightened demand for risk assessments related to pool installations and maintenance. Industry professionals, including members of the California Pool Association, are stepping in to guide homeowners through these complexities.

A Push Toward Sustainability

Pool owners are adopting sustainable practices, such as installing covers to reduce evaporation and using energy-efficient pumps. These measures can improve insurability by showcasing a commitment to environmental responsibility.
Swimming pool with a solar cover system, showcasing sustainable practices for water conservation."


Why the California Pool Association Is a Key Resource

The California Pool Association has emerged as a leading voice for pool owners navigating the current insurance landscape. By offering guidance on insurance challenges, advocating for fairer policies, and promoting best practices, the association plays a critical role in supporting its members during this crisis.


Conclusion

California’s homeowners’ insurance crisis has placed significant pressure on pool owners, from policy cancellations to higher premiums. Governor Newsom’s executive order may stabilize the broader market but challenges specific to the pool industry persist. Homeowners must take proactive steps to safeguard their coverage, and organizations like the California Pool Association are essential allies in this effort.


Sources and Citations

  1. California Pool Association – Homepage
  2. Governor Newsom’s Executive Order on Insurance
  3. California Department of Insurance – Climate Risks and Homeowners’ Insurance
  4. Wildfire and Drought Insurance Impact Report 2024
  5. Case Study: Insurance Challenges for Pool Owners

 

4o